Should the New York Giants Play Malik Nabers in Week 1?
The New York Giants open the 2026 season against the Dallas Cowboys, and naturally everyone wants to see Malik Nabers on the field.
But if he’s not 100 percent healthy, I think the Giants need to be patient.
I’m not saying Nabers won’t be ready. He very well could be. But if he’s only 80 or 90 percent, I don’t think it’s worth taking the risk. It’s Week 1 of a long season, not the playoffs. As exciting as opening against a division rival is, the Giants have to think bigger than one game.
Sometimes the Best Move Is Waiting
Dallas is always an important matchup, but the Giants play them twice every year. They know each other well, and they’ll have another opportunity later in the season.
If holding Nabers out for one more week means he’s fully healthy for the next four months, that’s an easy decision for me.
We’ve seen too many examples across sports where teams rush star players back only to watch them suffer another injury. During our discussion, we talked about similar situations in other sports where organizations prioritized the short term instead of the long-term health of their star players.
The Giants simply can’t afford to make that mistake with their franchise wide receiver.
This Season Is Bigger Than Week 1
One reason I’d be cautious is because I actually believe this Giants team has a chance to surprise people.
I’ve said before that I think this team can win somewhere between eight and ten games if things break their way. If that’s the expectation, then protecting one of your most important players becomes even more important.
There’s no sense jeopardizing the next 16 games just to force him onto the field for the first one.
If he’s healthy, great. Play him.
If not, let him heal.
Odell Beckham Jr. Gives the Giants Another Option
Since we recorded the podcast, the Giants officially signed Odell Beckham Jr., and I think there’s a very good chance he makes the final 53-man roster.
No, this isn’t the same Odell who took the league by storm as a rookie, and nobody should expect that version to return. But he doesn’t have to be that player to help this team.
If Malik Nabers isn’t ready for Week 1, having a veteran like Odell gives the Giants another capable receiver who understands the spotlight and can still contribute. That’s exactly why bringing him back made sense to me. He can help bridge the gap while Nabers gets back to full strength instead of forcing your young star onto the field before he’s ready.
And honestly, I’d love nothing more than to see Odell come back in a Giants uniform and torch the Cowboys in Week 1. That would be a pretty special way to begin the season. But even if that doesn’t happen, simply having another experienced playmaker available gives the Giants some flexibility and allows them to be patient with Malik Nabers’ recovery.
Final Thoughts
Every Giants fan wants to beat Dallas to open the season. There’s no question about that.
But this season is about much more than one game.
If Malik Nabers is completely healthy, put him on the field and let him go to work.
If he isn’t, the smart move is to wait.
The Giants believe they’ve built a team that can compete this season. Protecting one of the biggest pieces of that future is the right decision, even if it means waiting one more week.
At the end of the day, I’d rather have Malik Nabers available for 16 or 17 games than rush him back for one and risk losing him again. That’s the bigger picture the Giants need to keep in mind.
Rep The Team No Matter What!
Through the highs and the lows, we bleed blue. As a new season begins, there’s no better way to show your Giants pride than with the new Jaxson Dart New York Giants Jersey.
One of the team’s top-selling jerseys, it’s the perfect way to back Big Blue and represent the future of Giants football.
The New York Giants Fanatics Shop.
Ready for Redemption? Grab Tickets Now!
The past is behind us. A new season is coming, and hope is alive. Want to be there when the Giants start writing a new chapter? Head to StubHub to grab your tickets for the home opener at MetLife Stadium
More Giants Talk Every Week.
We’ll be covering more Giants drama, victories, and throwbacks every week. Don’t miss a post, subscribe below and stay in the loop all season long.
