QB Market Watch: Who Needs a Signal Caller?
The 2025 NFL Draft isn’t considered deep at quarterback. Most experts agree there are only two to four quarterbacks with true first-round grades. But that doesn’t mean teams lacking stability under center can afford to sit back and wait.
A few big names stand out — Cam Ward (Miami), Shedeur Sanders (Colorado), Jaxson Dart (Ole Miss), and Jalen Milroe (Alabama) — as possible Day 1 picks. However, there are also intriguing Day 2 or 3 options, such as Kyle McCord (Syracuse) and Tyler Shough (Louisville), who could develop into solid pros with the right coaching and patience.
Let’s break down the teams that should seriously consider drafting a quarterback in 2025. Let’s start the list with the Giants — after all, this is a New York Giants blog.
New York Giants
The Giants are holding the No. 3 and No. 34 overall picks, and it’s hard to imagine they don’t at least consider drafting a quarterback — especially with uncertainty swirling around the futures of Russell Wilson, Jameis Winston, and Tommy DeVito.
If Cam Ward, widely projected to be the first overall pick, is off the board to Tennessee, that leaves Shedeur Sanders as the next high-profile option. However, it wouldn’t be surprising if GM Joe Schoen and HC Brian Daboll decide to pass on Sanders. While he’s an exciting talent, questions remain about his fit and readiness for an NFL offense.
Instead, the Giants may opt to draft a blue-chip player at No. 3 — someone who can make an immediate impact — and then circle back for a quarterback at No. 34 or with a move up from that spot. If that’s the case, Jaxson Dart or Jalen Milroe become intriguing targets. Both are raw but have athletic upside and strong arms that Daboll might believe he can mold into long-term starters.
This strategy would be a gamble, but it also reflects the tightrope the Giants’ leadership is walking. Schoen and Daboll need to win now, but they also need a quarterback who can grow with the team. Dart or Milroe wouldn’t be expected to start right away, allowing the veterans to hold the fort while a young prospect develops behind the scenes.
With pressure mounting and the future uncertain, the Giants’ approach to the quarterback position could define this regime’s legacy — for better or worse.
Tennessee Titans
Will Levis hasn’t cemented himself, and their backups are over 30 with limited starts. Owning the No. 1 overall pick likely puts them in line for Cam Ward, a strong-armed, athletic option who could fit into their new offensive identity..
Cleveland Browns
Deshaun Watson’s injuries and inconsistency have left the Browns in limbo. Kenny Pickett hasn’t impressed, and while Joe Flacco is back, that’s not a long-term solution. With the second and 33rd picks, Cleveland is in a strong position to reset the quarterback room early in the draft.
Pittsburgh Steelers
The Steelers are one Rodgers decision away from needing a new plan. Even if he signs, Pittsburgh’s long-term outlook isn’t secure with only Mason Rudolph and Skylar Thompson behind him. A first-round developmental QB makes a lot of sense here.
New Orleans Saints
Derek Carr is under contract through 2026, but that doesn’t tell the full story. His salary spikes to $40 million in 2026 — and none of it is guaranteed. More pressing, however, is the shoulder injury he sustained late last season. While the team has been optimistic publicly, there’s growing concern that Carr’s recovery could impact his availability for the 2025 season.
Given that uncertainty, it makes sense for the Saints to consider drafting a quarterback — especially with a new head coach in Kellen Moore now leading the way. Taking one at No. 9 might be a stretch unless Shedeur Sanders falls into their lap.
New York Jets
The Jets should let Justin Fields sink or swim in 2025. Tyrod Taylor, 35, is a capable veteran. Unless a top prospect is sitting there at No. 7 or 42, drafting a QB doesn’t feel urgent — but this is the Jets we’re talking about.
Los Angeles Rams
Matthew Stafford, 37, is near the end, and Jimmy Garoppolo, 33, is a temporary backup. Stetson Bennett remains unproven after missing most of his rookie year. If a QB like Dart falls to them at 26, the Rams may finally invest in their future at the position.
Las Vegas Raiders
Geno Smith, now 35, is under contract through 2027, but he’s clearly a short-term bridge. The Raiders appear to view Aidan O’Connell as a backup. With Carter Bradley still unproven, a Day 2 option like Shough or McCord may be worth a look.
Seattle Seahawks
Seattle handed Sam Darnold a sizable deal, but it’s not ironclad. They can move on next year if needed. With five picks in the top 92, GM John Schneider could easily take a swing if someone like Sanders drops to them. Their current backups, Sam Howell and Jaren Hall, are set to hit free agency next year.
Predicting the QB Market in the 2025 NFL Draft was originally published by Bleedbigblue.com.
About Us.
BleedBigBlue.com burst onto the scene after a fiery social media rant about PSL’s and ticket prices went viral. Now, as your go-to New York Giants Blog, we’re still calling it like we see it!
Subscribe To Our Blog.
Be sure to subscribe to our blog. When we post new content, you’ll receive an email with all the latest updates, delivered in a non-spammy way!
