Home New York Giants Game Recap5 Reasons the Giants Lost to the Commanders

5 Reasons the Giants Lost to the Commanders

by Marco Ceo

The Giants fell 24–21 to the Commanders in Week 10 and missed a chance to extend their NFC East lead. A costly fumble, a missed field goal and a conservative third-down call left the door open for Jayden Daniels to lead Washington’s game-winning drive.

The New York Giants missed a chance to widen their NFC East lead Thursday night, falling 24–21 to the Washington Commanders in Week 10. J.J. McCarthy threw for 293 yards, Cam Skattebo ran for two touchdowns, and the defense came away with two interceptions. The Giants still left points on the field and gave Jayden Daniels a chance to win it late. Here are five reasons the game slipped away.

The first Giants-Commanders matchup ended in a 27–27 overtime tie, so Thursday night was Big Blue’s chance to settle the season series. Both games came down to whether the Giants could make one more play. In Week 5, they escaped with a tie and held on to first place. That’s what made the rematch feel like such a missed opportunity after the Giants’ Week 5 tie with Washington⁠.

1. The Giants got too conservative on third-and-3

The late third-and-3 call for McCarthy to run is the one I keep coming back to. He’d been pushing the ball downfield for most of the night, and the offensive line gave up just one sack. Isaiah Likely was having another big game, with nine catches for 127 yards and a touchdown. With a late first down on the line, I would’ve liked to see the Giants trust McCarthy to find Likely or another receiver past the sticks.

Isaiah Likely was one of the best answers the Giants had against Washington. He caught nine passes for 127 yards and a touchdown, which is why I wanted to see McCarthy get a chance to find him on that late third-and-3. With three yards to go, I’d have liked the Giants to give one of their most productive players a chance to move the chains. Those are the situations that make the Giants’ decision to sign Isaiah Likely⁠ look even better.

2. Two turnovers ended two chances to take the lead

Malik Nabers was finding his rhythm in the second half when his fumble cut short a promising drive. The Giants were in position to take the lead and came away empty. They got another shot late, and J.J. McCarthy went back to Nabers with pressure closing in. This time, Washington came away with the game-ending interception.

I expect a receiver of Nabers’ caliber to make that catch, though maybe I’m asking a little too much there. It was a decent throw under pressure, and McCarthy gave him a chance to make a play. Isaiah Likely was open underneath, and a completion to him could have set up fourth-and-short. I could’ve lived with an incompletion in that spot because the Giants would still have had one more down. The interception ended it.

Those turnovers were especially frustrating given how much Cam Skattebo had done to keep the offense moving. He ran for 78 yards and two touchdowns and added 44 yards receiving. His 122 yards from scrimmage showed how much the Giants can get out of him when they keep him involved in the passing game. We saw him help Big Blue finish a close game in the Giants’ Week 7 overtime win over the Texans⁠.

3. The pass rush gave Jayden Daniels too much room

Four days after recording seven sacks against Philadelphia, the Giants got to Daniels just once. Arvell Reese still finished with 13 tackles, and Jevon Holland grabbed his fourth interception of the season, his first since Week 3. The Giants picked off Daniels twice, but they couldn’t end Washington’s final drive. Daniels led the Commanders to the winning score and improved to 4–0–1 against Big Blue.

I barely heard Kayvon Thibodeaux’s name on the broadcast Thursday night, and the only time I remember it coming up was when he got banged up. That’s way too quiet on a night when the Giants needed someone to get to Jayden Daniels. Thibodeaux has played in all nine games this season and still hasn’t recorded a sack. That makes him one of the more interesting Giants to watch this offseason. What kind of market will he have, and will a team still be willing to give him a big deal?

4. A late flag overshadowed Deonte Banks’ rebound

The late pass interference call on Deonte Banks gave Washington a boost when the Giants needed a stop. From what I saw, Treylon Burks pulled Banks toward him and did a good job selling the contact. A few missed tackles and late flags have understandably left a bad taste with some Giants fans. Even with those rough moments, Banks is playing some of his best football since his rookie year.

Banks has 11 passes defended through Week 10, and his lone interception was the 98-yard pick-six that sealed the Giants’ Week 4 win over the Cardinals. The PFF tracking numbers point to how much tougher he’s been to throw against, with a league-leading five forced incompletions in man coverage, a 48.7% completion rate allowed and just 4.2 yards allowed per target. That’s a strong rebound in a contract year after the Giants declined his fifth-year option. If Banks can clean up the missed tackles and late penalties, he’ll give the Giants a real decision to make this offseason.

5. Dominic Zvada’s 33-yard miss exposed a recurring issue

Dominic Zvada hooked a 33-yard field goal in a game the Giants lost by three. All six of his missed field goals this season have come from the right hash, including Thursday night’s miss against Washington. The Giants have lined up on the left hash for every extra point, and Zvada is a perfect 16-for-16 on those attempts. That’s a pattern worth paying attention to, especially when the miss comes from the same distance as an extra point.

Some Giants fans are calling for the team to move on, but John Harbaugh is sticking with his rookie kicker. Harbaugh said the staff is looking at how Zvada positions his plant foot on kicks from the right hash. I understand giving him time to fix it, especially after he hit all four field goals in the rain in the Giants’ 12–7 win over the Titans. With seven games left and an NFC East lead to protect, I want to see that work translate into makes from the right hash when the Giants need three points.

The Giants still lead the NFC East

Big Blue is still in first place at 5–3–1, two games ahead of Dallas and Washington in the loss column. A win would have moved the Giants to 3–0–1 in the NFC East and given them more breathing room. Instead, they’re 2–1–1 in the division, and Washington owns the head-to-head tiebreaker after a win and a tie in the season series. The AFC South-leading Jacksonville Jaguars are up next, with seven games left for the Giants to protect their lead. The silver lining is that it’s mid-November and Big Blue is playing meaningful football again, something Giants fans have been waiting for since 2022.

Blue Nfl Football Jersey with a Large White Number 6 Outlined in Red Red and White Sleeve Stripes and a Nike Swoosh on the Left Sleeve
Men's Nike Dri-FIT NFL Limited Jersey

Jaxson Dart Jersey

Available now!

Ready for Redemption? Grab Tickets Now!

The past is behind us. A new season is coming, and hope is alive. Want to be there when the Giants start writing a new chapter? Head to StubHub to grab your tickets for the home opener at MetLife Stadium

Never Miss An Update!

Don’t miss a post, subscribe below and stay in the loop all season long!

You may also like

Leave a Comment