Will New Coaching Revive Two Giants First-Round Picks?

The New York Giants have invested heavily in first-round talent over the past several years, but two players remain at a crossroads: Evan Neal and Deonte Banks. Both have shown flashes of why they were selected in the first round, yet neither has consistently lived up to expectations. With a new coaching staff in place, the question Giants fans are asking is simple: Will new coaching revive two Giants first-round picks?

Deonte Banks Needs a Fresh Start

Deonte Banks looked like a player the Giants could build around during his rookie season under then-defensive coordinator Wink Martindale. While he wasn’t perfect, he showed the athleticism, confidence, and physicality that made him a first-round selection. Instead of taking the next step, however, his play regressed over the past two seasons.

One of the more surprising developments last season was how Banks was utilized. At times, he was used more as a kick returner than a cornerback, and he actually performed well in that role. While his athletic ability was evident on special teams, Giants fans would much rather see him making plays in the secondary.

Now, Banks gets a fresh start under defensive coordinator Dennard Wilson, whose reputation for developing defensive backs gives Giants fans reason for optimism. More importantly, head coach John Harbaugh has brought a completely different philosophy to New York. Harbaugh has assembled a coaching staff filled with experienced teachers and former NFL head coaches, creating an environment that emphasizes accountability, fundamentals, and player development. That kind of culture could be exactly what Banks needs to regain the confidence and consistency he showed as a rookie.

Can Evan Neal Finally Turn the Corner?

It’s been a rough start to Evan Neal’s NFL career. The former Alabama standout hasn’t looked like the dominant offensive tackle Giants fans watched during his college career at Alabama, where he established himself as one of the nation’s premier linemen and a first-round draft pick. Injuries, inconsistent play, and constant changes have all contributed to a frustrating start.

Despite those struggles, Neal’s commitment to the organization says a lot about his character. After becoming a free agent this offseason, he chose to return to the Giants on an affordable contract instead of looking elsewhere. That decision speaks volumes about his belief in the organization and his willingness to earn his place rather than simply chase a bigger payday.

The new coaching staff could be exactly what Neal needs. Head coach John Harbaugh has assembled one of the NFL’s most experienced staffs, including offensive coordinator Matt Nagy and several former NFL head coaches. For an offensive lineman still trying to establish himself, having that level of experience and coaching on his side of the ball could make all the difference.

Looking back at the previous regime, it’s fair to question how much young talent truly developed. Outside of Daniel Jones’ resurgence in 2022, there aren’t many examples of players making significant leaps. That’s why this coaching change feels so important—not just for Neal and Banks, but for the future of the Giants’ roster as a whole.

Both players still possess the physical tools that made them first-round picks. The talent has never been the question. The Giants are betting that a new coaching staff, fresh leadership, and a stronger developmental culture can unlock the potential that made Evan Neal and Deonte Banks first-round selections.

The talent is there. The coaching staff is in place. Now it’s up to Evan Neal and Deonte Banks to take advantage of the opportunity in front of them.

The only question left is this: Will new coaching revive two Giants first-round picks?